Here's another valentine idea.
My girls are candy-a-holics, so the more candy they could incorporate into their valentines, the better! We came up with the idea to use Pixy Stix as "fishing poles" with a candy "catch" on the end. We used yarn to tie them together and attached a note that says, "You're A Great Catch". This idea could also be done using pencils and pretty much anything as the "catch". A baggie full of Swedish Fish candies would be really cute!
(tip: to prevent tangling, don't make the string too long!)
My Little Sienna is very happy with her catch!
P.S. We found big bags of Pixy Stix in the dollar bins at Target.